Seb J.
Got this at the Philly PRFM, really happy with the results! Application-wise, it's smooth and the color is very pigmented, yet not heavy or irritating. It's smudge-proof and water-proof, but comes off easily with a wipe and in the shower.
Jaime
Smooth to use. Loved it.
Esther A.
This obsidian eyeliner turned out to be the first thing from Baby Bat that I tried. I had already placed my second order and was quite impressed with the company and website.
It surprised me, therefore, how disappointing obsidian was. The stain looked watery, not strong and solid, going on, and then it immediately crept into creases in my eyelid that I didn’t know I even had. I had to remove it and use a different product before going out.
Maybe I should have shaken it more. I also bought the Nox eyeshadow palette, and it performed very well.
Margarita A.
I continue to try different eyeliners, but this continues to top them all. It really is my favorite and love that it's from a goth <3
Keely S.
Really loving this eyeliner! It’s so dark and inky black, it’s perfect. It’s really easy to apply as well and normally I struggle with liquid liners. Worth it for sure!
Megan H.
I cannot overstate how awesome this eyeliner is. It is the best I've ever used, bar none, and I've tried the big brands. This blows them out of the water, *and* it's cheaper. It's a solid, opaque black and smudge resistant. If I'm in a hurry, I can use it sans primer without any issue. I'm never going to use anything else!
Y P.
If you want a liquid liner that’s gonna be more reliable than any person you ever met—THIS IS THE ONE! It’s surviving the rain, the very beginning of the movie UP, the sweat of your partner as you getting back shots, cutting onions. The best liner for when you need it to last all day and into the next day.
Caitlin L.
This eyeliner is amazing!! It dries instantly and doesn't seem to smudge/takes a long time to come off naturally but it comes off so easy in the shower/with makeup wipes. I've only ever tried their eyeshadows before and I'm so happy with the quality of their products.
Richard C.
This is my second time purchasing this eyeliner because I'm in love with it and have purchased another for a friend to try. I have never been a fan of these pencil liners because they tend to go on too watery/too dry/not enough comes out, but this is the first one that I find completely perfect!! It dries quickly but you can make clean lines at one stroke and does not budge or run at all afterwards. I do use a little bit of primer first (urban decay) but compared to all the other liners I've tried, this doesn't compare. I have even fallen asleep with it by accident & the next morning it looks like I just applied it. I'm curious about trying the other colors but this is my go-to fancy black eyeliner that I use on special full make up nights. <3
Diana C.
I LOVE the liner! Perfect cat eye every time, lasts FOREVER and does not dry/flake/irritate my eyes like other liners do after a few hours! I’ve already come back for my second one even though I haven’t finished the first. 10/10 would recommend! (Also pictured is the afterlife lipgloss)
Kelly M.
This is one of the best liquid liners I've tried. I use liquid a lot. I used to only like the brush because the line was much smoother than the felt tips. This one has a very bendable tip and works SO WELL!! I love it!!
